The Bottom Line: "Great"
It was a good ep. The writing was good and overall the ep was emotional. Even though Q wasn't my favorite character, this ep was pretty good in showing the lives he touched.
I liked the narration by Samantha. The essay she wrote about Q was pretty good. But I thought Haley was a complete witch telling her to move, and then again with the snarky Clothes over Bros remark.
Surprisingly, the Jamie scenes were downplayed which was good. I thought it would all be about him, but, it seemed natural. He was quiet for the most part and even the scenes with him and Q's little brother were palatable. Surprisingly Luke didn't seem to have that prominent a role. Yeah, he was seen a few times talking to the team and with Peyton, but the ep really wasn't about him as much as it was about the others.
Skills-Deb was okay. I liked how she was there for him when Nate had Haley, Luke had Peyton, etc., but I'm still hoping they end their affair.
The Brooke story was intriguing. Was she raped? I dont' know. But it did seem odd that she didn't make any effort to cover up the bruises on her body, when she tried so hard to conceal her black eyes, makes you wonder.
And, as much as I don't like the Nanny Carrie storyline, I actually felt sorry for her with the reveal of her dead son's grave. But, that sorrow didn't last long when I saw the previews for next week when she kidnaps Jamie's bunny (totally ripping off "Fatal Attraction").
A few minor quibbles though, some of the lines said in the ep seemed stitled and forced.
Q's line, "how does a mother breathe?", seemed really odd. Why would he say that? That seems like a scripted line, not something a 22-year-old guy would just say.
Jamie's cape thing at the end was emotional, I guess, but I asked this question before: had Q lived, would he have really worn it? I'm sure he would have thanked Jamie for it and wore it once to humor him, but after that, he would have put it in his closet or something.