"Paranoia Agent" ends. ...For me.
Some shows are so good, that one will do just about anything to see the next episode as soon as possible. Well, I got Paranoia Agent (and a few other anime items) on DVD a week ago, and watched the last 4 episodes in one sitting.
That said, I am convinced that PA is one of the best mystery shows ever created.
****SPOILERS BELOW****
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Except not quite here.
Just a fair warning so you don't have any regrets: I won't divulge the details just yet, but what I will say in the meantime, is the basic answer to the mystery.
***READ AT YOUR OWN RISK...SERIOUSLY, THIS TIME***
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
That theory that I conceived in my last blog entry?
It's almost right on the ball.
I kid you not. I'm proud to say that for the first time ever, I've pretty much solved a mystery (and a very difficult one at that.) Lil' Slugger IS in fact a figment of Tsukiko Sagi's imagination. I won't say why, but I will say the number 1 in the old man's equation indeed does apply to Lil' Slugger.
How?
Because the paranoia is produced by ONE person (in this case, Tsukiko Sagi) and then, it spreads like a sickness, as I reasoned in my previous blog entry. The paranoia grows stronger and stronger, which explains why eventually, Lil' Slugger began killing people instead of just knocking them out. (Of course, that's all metaphorical. In actuality, everyone except Ushiyama and Hirukawa was knocked out by THEMSELVES, and not Kozuka.) Ultimately, the paranoia acts like a virus; it starts out small-scale, and then it infects everything.
Hence the title: "Paranoia Agent." Dun dun dunnn!
All in all, the last 4 episodes are great and I will be certain to review them in detail when I have more time. "Paranoia Agent" has been a real blast and I do hope that Mr. Satoshi Kon makes something else that's just as diabolically ingenious in the near future. Or else... *raises bat*
Posted by ldcubed, 08/05/2005 12:20pm
0 Comments
That said, I am convinced that PA is one of the best mystery shows ever created.
****SPOILERS BELOW****
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Except not quite here.
Just a fair warning so you don't have any regrets: I won't divulge the details just yet, but what I will say in the meantime, is the basic answer to the mystery.
***READ AT YOUR OWN RISK...SERIOUSLY, THIS TIME***
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
That theory that I conceived in my last blog entry?
It's almost right on the ball.
I kid you not. I'm proud to say that for the first time ever, I've pretty much solved a mystery (and a very difficult one at that.) Lil' Slugger IS in fact a figment of Tsukiko Sagi's imagination. I won't say why, but I will say the number 1 in the old man's equation indeed does apply to Lil' Slugger.
How?
Because the paranoia is produced by ONE person (in this case, Tsukiko Sagi) and then, it spreads like a sickness, as I reasoned in my previous blog entry. The paranoia grows stronger and stronger, which explains why eventually, Lil' Slugger began killing people instead of just knocking them out. (Of course, that's all metaphorical. In actuality, everyone except Ushiyama and Hirukawa was knocked out by THEMSELVES, and not Kozuka.) Ultimately, the paranoia acts like a virus; it starts out small-scale, and then it infects everything.
Hence the title: "Paranoia Agent." Dun dun dunnn!
All in all, the last 4 episodes are great and I will be certain to review them in detail when I have more time. "Paranoia Agent" has been a real blast and I do hope that Mr. Satoshi Kon makes something else that's just as diabolically ingenious in the near future. Or else... *raises bat*
The Truth Is...
What is truth?
"Etc.", episode 9 of Paranoia Agent, helps clarify this (or further distort, depending on the way you look at it.)
So far, to the audience, Lil' Slugger's identity and purpose is an enigma (thanks to contradictory and/or new evidence presented each episode.) Like the audience, the group of gossipers is also speculating as to what Lil' Slugger is up to. Ironically enough though...it is the very idea of the gossiping in the episode that appears to hold a major piece of the puzzle in solving this totally "whacked" mystery.
Every story told in "Etc." deviated completely from the way Lil' Slugger would normally slug someone. This is not to say that they *all* went on wild tangents (most of them did), but there was always something distinct in each of the stories that had an aura of absurdity to it in comparison to the way the Lil' Slugger stories were told in the first 7 episodes (save episode 5, which was like watching a metaphor within a metaphor.)
I'm also guesstimating that when the writer's wife said, "But that's a famous..." (only to be subsequently cut off by the other women), I think she was trying to say that the incident was taken from a famous novel or movie. I don't just say this because it seems like the best fit; I say it mainly because the way the story was presented seemed slightly melodramatic for real life (or rather, anime life.) If this is true, then this would also probably contribute to the "Maromi being popular and acting as a medium" idea somehow.
Another thing that I noticed in this episode was the recurrence of the number 4. First, if you look at how the gossiping women wave their hands, it looks like (to me anyway) that they tuck their thumbs in (hence presenting 4 fingers.) Second, the wall of the nervous student has the number 4 on it. And lastly, the number 4 is heard is when the boxer reaches the 3rd plate of food. Perhaps even more importantly, it is the 4th time he stops that he sees Lil' Slugger with the whole buffet.
What does this mean?
Well...episode 4 was when Kozuka was captured. It's also when Hirukawa DIDN'T get rendered unconscious. To me, episodes 4 and 7 are pivotal turning points. In episodes 1-4, we had standard procedure: people being whacked into unconscious-ness. In episodes 5 and 6, there was a bit of a limbo-like period. In episode 6, specifically, we found out that Lil' Slugger still existed despite Kozuka's arrest. But then, in episode 7, a major turning point: Lil' Slugger kills. And since episode 7, that's what he's been doing.
One could also make the case that Lil' Slugger's power has been increasing every episode, considering the fact that in episode 6, Hirukawa's daughter got amnesia. It's really quite ambiguous at this point as to how Lil' Slugger's power is being altered, increased, distorted, etc. so I'm not going to jump to any conclusions just yet.
Probably the most interesting thing I noticed though, in "Etc." was the abundance of the circle. Yes, the shape. Or at least, a circular-like shape. To be specific: the gossipers' circle, the room that the student was taking the test in, the mother's womb, the baseball players huddling around the pitcher (plus the baseball stadium itself), and finally, the island in the middle of nowhere with the palm tree on it. What is the significance of this? Well...
Two takes on it:
1. Entrapment
and
2. Letting something go on and on so much, that it simply turns into something near-ridiculous.
Perhaps Lil' Slugger is a complete fabrication altogether.
We know that the Old Man's equation beared the number 1 in it. So perhaps Lil' Slugger was just a figment of Tsukiko Sagi's imagination, a stand alone complex (a la Ghost in the Shell) if you will. Tsukiko saw Kozuka somewhere before and imagined that he attacked her(?) Kozuka himself then got wind of Lil' Slugger and began to mimic him via the holy warrior image. Next, thanks to *Kozuka's* influence, the rumor of Lil' Slugger spread even moreso. Finally, with Maniwa playing the role of the messenger, the rumor of Lil' Slugger is spread everywhere. Hence, people began to believe that Lil' Slugger was the person who was attacking people instead of the people themselves. What I wouldn't understand under this theory is how Lil' Slugger's power "increased." Perhaps the more people knew about Lil' Slugger, the more harm they inflicted upon themselves? And if my theory is true, how can the virus that is Lil' Slugger be stopped? Does it have something to do with Maromi, the *other* popular culture item?
It all sounds a bit convoluted, I know, but I think the important thing to remember is that somehow, Lil' Slugger has SOMETHING to do with the idea of 1, and that truth is a very subjective term.
That's my two cents for now.
All in a all, another fantabulous episode with very insightful things to present. I can't wait to see what happens next!
Posted by ldcubed, 07/24/2005 4:59pm
0 Comments
"Etc.", episode 9 of Paranoia Agent, helps clarify this (or further distort, depending on the way you look at it.)
So far, to the audience, Lil' Slugger's identity and purpose is an enigma (thanks to contradictory and/or new evidence presented each episode.) Like the audience, the group of gossipers is also speculating as to what Lil' Slugger is up to. Ironically enough though...it is the very idea of the gossiping in the episode that appears to hold a major piece of the puzzle in solving this totally "whacked" mystery.
Every story told in "Etc." deviated completely from the way Lil' Slugger would normally slug someone. This is not to say that they *all* went on wild tangents (most of them did), but there was always something distinct in each of the stories that had an aura of absurdity to it in comparison to the way the Lil' Slugger stories were told in the first 7 episodes (save episode 5, which was like watching a metaphor within a metaphor.)
I'm also guesstimating that when the writer's wife said, "But that's a famous..." (only to be subsequently cut off by the other women), I think she was trying to say that the incident was taken from a famous novel or movie. I don't just say this because it seems like the best fit; I say it mainly because the way the story was presented seemed slightly melodramatic for real life (or rather, anime life.) If this is true, then this would also probably contribute to the "Maromi being popular and acting as a medium" idea somehow.
Another thing that I noticed in this episode was the recurrence of the number 4. First, if you look at how the gossiping women wave their hands, it looks like (to me anyway) that they tuck their thumbs in (hence presenting 4 fingers.) Second, the wall of the nervous student has the number 4 on it. And lastly, the number 4 is heard is when the boxer reaches the 3rd plate of food. Perhaps even more importantly, it is the 4th time he stops that he sees Lil' Slugger with the whole buffet.
What does this mean?
Well...episode 4 was when Kozuka was captured. It's also when Hirukawa DIDN'T get rendered unconscious. To me, episodes 4 and 7 are pivotal turning points. In episodes 1-4, we had standard procedure: people being whacked into unconscious-ness. In episodes 5 and 6, there was a bit of a limbo-like period. In episode 6, specifically, we found out that Lil' Slugger still existed despite Kozuka's arrest. But then, in episode 7, a major turning point: Lil' Slugger kills. And since episode 7, that's what he's been doing.
One could also make the case that Lil' Slugger's power has been increasing every episode, considering the fact that in episode 6, Hirukawa's daughter got amnesia. It's really quite ambiguous at this point as to how Lil' Slugger's power is being altered, increased, distorted, etc. so I'm not going to jump to any conclusions just yet.
Probably the most interesting thing I noticed though, in "Etc." was the abundance of the circle. Yes, the shape. Or at least, a circular-like shape. To be specific: the gossipers' circle, the room that the student was taking the test in, the mother's womb, the baseball players huddling around the pitcher (plus the baseball stadium itself), and finally, the island in the middle of nowhere with the palm tree on it. What is the significance of this? Well...
Two takes on it:
1. Entrapment
and
2. Letting something go on and on so much, that it simply turns into something near-ridiculous.
Perhaps Lil' Slugger is a complete fabrication altogether.
We know that the Old Man's equation beared the number 1 in it. So perhaps Lil' Slugger was just a figment of Tsukiko Sagi's imagination, a stand alone complex (a la Ghost in the Shell) if you will. Tsukiko saw Kozuka somewhere before and imagined that he attacked her(?) Kozuka himself then got wind of Lil' Slugger and began to mimic him via the holy warrior image. Next, thanks to *Kozuka's* influence, the rumor of Lil' Slugger spread even moreso. Finally, with Maniwa playing the role of the messenger, the rumor of Lil' Slugger is spread everywhere. Hence, people began to believe that Lil' Slugger was the person who was attacking people instead of the people themselves. What I wouldn't understand under this theory is how Lil' Slugger's power "increased." Perhaps the more people knew about Lil' Slugger, the more harm they inflicted upon themselves? And if my theory is true, how can the virus that is Lil' Slugger be stopped? Does it have something to do with Maromi, the *other* popular culture item?
It all sounds a bit convoluted, I know, but I think the important thing to remember is that somehow, Lil' Slugger has SOMETHING to do with the idea of 1, and that truth is a very subjective term.
That's my two cents for now.
All in a all, another fantabulous episode with very insightful things to present. I can't wait to see what happens next!
"Happy Family Planning, or How I Learned to Make an Ingeniously Twisted Show"
Episode 8 of Paranoia Agent:
Happy Family Planning? Those writers sure have a sense of wicked, twisted humor.
I'll keep this one shorter. If you thought Paranoia Agent was messed up before, this one takes the cake. The best way to describe this episode is...
"*laughs and shakes head*
Oh my god..."
A nice combination, wouldn't ya say?
Well, it's like that at least until the end of the episode anyway. The fact that even the suicide gang (namely the old man) was afraid of being trapped in a corner was slowly unraveled. At that point, I could feel the secondary, dark forboding tone of the episode coming to fruition.
Everyone keeps saying that this episode has nothing to do with the previous 7, but it definitely does (why else would it be a part of the series?) I mean, of course the episode made a point of proving that even Lil' Slugger was afraid of them, (then again, was that REALLY Lil' Slugger?) and that conversely, even the dead are afraid. But also, remember the radio frequency? Double-trouble? Perhaps it all has something to do with tapping through to the dead (though I doubt that would be the final conclusion.)
Do discuss! Perhaps keeping this post shorter than the last PA post will make you want to say some-
thing.
Posted by ldcubed, 07/19/2005 2:46pm
0 Comments
Happy Family Planning? Those writers sure have a sense of wicked, twisted humor.
I'll keep this one shorter. If you thought Paranoia Agent was messed up before, this one takes the cake. The best way to describe this episode is...
"*laughs and shakes head*
Oh my god..."
A nice combination, wouldn't ya say?
Well, it's like that at least until the end of the episode anyway. The fact that even the suicide gang (namely the old man) was afraid of being trapped in a corner was slowly unraveled. At that point, I could feel the secondary, dark forboding tone of the episode coming to fruition.
Everyone keeps saying that this episode has nothing to do with the previous 7, but it definitely does (why else would it be a part of the series?) I mean, of course the episode made a point of proving that even Lil' Slugger was afraid of them, (then again, was that REALLY Lil' Slugger?) and that conversely, even the dead are afraid. But also, remember the radio frequency? Double-trouble? Perhaps it all has something to do with tapping through to the dead (though I doubt that would be the final conclusion.)
Do discuss! Perhaps keeping this post shorter than the last PA post will make you want to say some-
thing.
Is Family Guy still the same?
I'm worried.
Okay, not WORRIED, but concerned. ...That really wasn't much of a euphemism, was it?
Anyway, I'm *concerned* that the Family Guy may be trying too hard at certain points in its new episodes. While there HAVE been episodes that were more about cultural commentary than just strictly characterization, it seems that some of the jokes have become not just random, but sophomoric.
In other words: They're targeting young teens (aka the male version of the AI crowd)
Either that, or they're losing their edge.
BUT DON'T VENT YET. WAIT.
I'm not done yet.
I still think that most of the episodes have been very funny, and I appreciate the fact that the writers have been listening in on their audience's
favorite things (i.e. the evil monkey.) Plus, I like how FG slowly, but surely re-integrated characters other than the Griffins back into the mix this season. They've really done quite a number with Quagmire and Cleveland (but especially Quagmire) this season, and that's a plus.
Also, from the last episode: a nice reference to the Brian/Lois relationship.
The most important thing though, that I'd like to mention is the use of references/flashbacks in general. A lot of them are still hilarious, but maybe I'm just not as "inside" as I should be, as I am having a MUCH more difficult time getting the reference jokes; they seem so obscure now. Granted, certain episodes have swung one way more than others (e.g. the episode where Meg became a star had a nice blend, while the Cleveland-Loretta Quagmire episode was more character-driven.) Does anyone else feel this way??
I still like FG (it wouldn't be listed as one of my favorite shows after all), but I am perplexed sometimes. I am concerned that FG will become what the Simpsons has come in the past several years. In other words: focusing a lot more on inside character jokes and not making as many cultural jokes that would appeal to a wide array of people (or if not that, simply being less *clever* in making those jokes.)
Though considering how FG seems to have a bit of a rivalry with The Simpsons, I'm not too worried.
(hence concerned)
Posted by ldcubed, 07/19/2005 2:38pm
0 Comments
Okay, not WORRIED, but concerned. ...That really wasn't much of a euphemism, was it?
Anyway, I'm *concerned* that the Family Guy may be trying too hard at certain points in its new episodes. While there HAVE been episodes that were more about cultural commentary than just strictly characterization, it seems that some of the jokes have become not just random, but sophomoric.
In other words: They're targeting young teens (aka the male version of the AI crowd)
Either that, or they're losing their edge.
BUT DON'T VENT YET. WAIT.
I'm not done yet.
I still think that most of the episodes have been very funny, and I appreciate the fact that the writers have been listening in on their audience's
favorite things (i.e. the evil monkey.) Plus, I like how FG slowly, but surely re-integrated characters other than the Griffins back into the mix this season. They've really done quite a number with Quagmire and Cleveland (but especially Quagmire) this season, and that's a plus.
Also, from the last episode: a nice reference to the Brian/Lois relationship.
The most important thing though, that I'd like to mention is the use of references/flashbacks in general. A lot of them are still hilarious, but maybe I'm just not as "inside" as I should be, as I am having a MUCH more difficult time getting the reference jokes; they seem so obscure now. Granted, certain episodes have swung one way more than others (e.g. the episode where Meg became a star had a nice blend, while the Cleveland-Loretta Quagmire episode was more character-driven.) Does anyone else feel this way??
I still like FG (it wouldn't be listed as one of my favorite shows after all), but I am perplexed sometimes. I am concerned that FG will become what the Simpsons has come in the past several years. In other words: focusing a lot more on inside character jokes and not making as many cultural jokes that would appeal to a wide array of people (or if not that, simply being less *clever* in making those jokes.)
Though considering how FG seems to have a bit of a rivalry with The Simpsons, I'm not too worried.
(hence concerned)
Paranoia Agent: Episode 7 Analysis
If anyone out there is following this show, PLEASE respond. PA is definitely one of the must-see cult shows today (anime shows rather, which have a cult following in themselves), so it's not every day that I get the chance to talk about it.
I suppose the best thing to do right now would be to go over the last episode (episode 7) and make some comments. ...Or a detailed analysis.
***EPISODE REVIEW BELOW. READ AT YOUR OWN RISK.***
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
*ahem*
The last episode took a very unexpected turn: Kozuka, the Lil' Slugger suspect, was KILLED. By Lil' Slugger.
Huh? What? Who? Where? When? Why? How?
Moo?
The secret to this strange occurrence appears to lie within the subconscious of our slowly-emerging protagonist, young detective Manawa (sp?) Or at least, his Lynchian-like dreams.
Remember those Doublemint commercials? You know, the snarkily fun ones with twins? And remember the Teen Titans episode where Mumbo traps the TTs in his hat and he has a magic show where everyone in the audience looks like him? Well, try to think of both of those things, except even more messed up. That's kind of what Manawa's first dream is like. If you haven't seen either of those things, that's okay; you are now officially integrated into "the fantabulous world of double, or how I learned to write scenes of stoner genius nature" (David Lynch used milkshakes for his highs, so go figure.)
Moving on.
So, the Old Man appears in Manawa's dream in a magic show. Appropriately, as the show has already begun to hint, the old kook is seemingly the original architect behind what is happening to the characters of PA. In the video game, he was an ancient master. This time, he's a magician, and he has some tricks up his sleeve (if you can find me another appropriate, yet less clichéd saying, I'd like to hear it. ...Besides the hat one.) Suddenly…
One Old Man.
Two Old Men.
HUNDREDS OF OLD MEN.
TOO. MANY. OLD MEN.
*regains composure*
What is the significance behind "double?" (Besides the parallel at the end of this episode, that is.) Well, here's a theory of mine that might bridge it all together:
The Old Man created the video game that Kozuka was playing and reenacting. Based on the fact that we saw the moon in this episode (also depicted in conjunction with Manawa operating some kind of broadcast system or recorder, it seems that frequency somehow plays an important part in bringing Lil' Slugger to life. Somehow or another, the game that the Old Man created must have had some kind of glitch in it, and whatever that glitch was, it caused things to happen in the real world that would normally happen in a fantasy world. The Old Man was then soon driven into insanity (or senility), trying to figure out the answer to some kind of equation. This equation that he's trying to solve seems to give the answer to how the chain of events involving Lil' Slugger was instigated.
A second theory that I have based on the way the PA commercials have been formatted is that Lil’ Slugger was a mythological tale of some sort that has existed for centuries. Or perhaps it’s a fusion of the two theories. Ultimately though, by all logic, all signs SOMEHOW point to Maromi, the pink plush doll of definite weirdness.
On a symbolic/thematic scale, there is also something at work which hasn't completely been tied together. It can be deduced that somehow or another, Maromi is an incarnation of Goma, or something similar to that. The question being: If Goma really is paranoia, then what does that mean? How did Goma come into existence for that matter? And why did we not receive a direct answer from the old woman about what Goma really is (in episode 6) if she was supposed to know that information? Was it embedded in her words? Could it have something to do with the idea of her family being torn apart? Do all of the victims now share a bond with each other because of their experiences with Lil’ Slugger? Will I stop asking questions? Yes.
There is also the matter of what the significance of the game metaphor really is, as well as the opening credits and ending credits. First, we know that the Holy Warrior attacks people who are glowing red. People glow red when they are paranoid, presumably. Hence, something that is unclear is whether or not Hirukawa was “red” at the time he was attacked. As far as we know, he was not attacked by Lil’ Slugger and was only hit by Kozuka, considering that he was not rendered unconscious; everyone attacked by Lil’ Slugger so far has experienced the same fate. Thus, chances are that Hirukawa probably took the pill that was given to him by the slimy mob guy, and in turn, became "yellow" (perhaps even green, if we’re going with stoplights here.) But even if this is true, then there is still one problem: Hirukawa still felt trapped at the time, just like the other victims (well, mostly. Keep reading.)
This leads me to believe that there is indeed some kind of catalyst that allows Goma to take over its victims, hence bringing a new idea to the table: Hirukawa was not around whatever this catalyst was. OR, simply put, the pill that Hirukawa took somehow NEGATED the effects of the catalyst. Considering how the first four victims had direct contact with each other, it seems to add up. What I don’t understand is how Kozuka and Hirukawa’s daughter got knocked out under this particular theory. Sure, it makes sense in terms of the paranoia idea, but there’s still something else. Conversely, how Ushiyama got attacked by Lil’ Slugger is a mystery to me. Of course, we didn’t really see his side of the story. As of now, the only possible conclusion that I can make is that Maromi was used by all of the victims. ...Or something.
The intro credits: Everyone is laughing. Why? Is it because they are not afraid of anything any more? Or is it a reverse reaction caused by their paranoia?
The end credits: There is significance to the Crane noise in the background. Somehow, it has something to do with Tsusigo Sagi. I just can’t remember exactly. Also, the order in which the victims are shown appears to be significant, as well as the brief flashes of them (now that we’ve learned of the double idea, it appears that the flash has something to do with that.) Also, the way Manawa is positioned in the circle has relevance. And of course, a giant Maromi in the center.
And so, it ends. Oh wait. No it doesn’t! Let’s talk about Detective Manawa. There is a whole crapload of irony coming his way. Why? Well, now he is AWARE of the fact that Lil’ Slugger goes after people who are paranoid. And now that he is having dreams in which he finds himself surrounded by strange things, he too, feels trapped in a corner. He feels paranoid BECAUSE of Lil Slugger's existence. Talk about paradox-o-rama! When will he be knocked out by Lil’ Slugger? My guess is near the final episode. There are still others that have yet to be slugged, including the old woman, the older detective, and another woman.
Now it really ends. Okay, not quite. There is still one final matter at hand. A disturbing one. Why, unlike the rest of the victims, was Kozuka KILLED!? (or committed suicide.) Was it because he tried to mimic something that already existed? Or it something else?
My head is spinning. Is yours?
Thanks for reading! Once again, respond if you can. I look forward to more commentary.
Posted by ldcubed, 07/15/2005 3:38pm
0 Comments
I suppose the best thing to do right now would be to go over the last episode (episode 7) and make some comments. ...Or a detailed analysis.
***EPISODE REVIEW BELOW. READ AT YOUR OWN RISK.***
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
*ahem*
The last episode took a very unexpected turn: Kozuka, the Lil' Slugger suspect, was KILLED. By Lil' Slugger.
Huh? What? Who? Where? When? Why? How?
Moo?
The secret to this strange occurrence appears to lie within the subconscious of our slowly-emerging protagonist, young detective Manawa (sp?) Or at least, his Lynchian-like dreams.
Remember those Doublemint commercials? You know, the snarkily fun ones with twins? And remember the Teen Titans episode where Mumbo traps the TTs in his hat and he has a magic show where everyone in the audience looks like him? Well, try to think of both of those things, except even more messed up. That's kind of what Manawa's first dream is like. If you haven't seen either of those things, that's okay; you are now officially integrated into "the fantabulous world of double, or how I learned to write scenes of stoner genius nature" (David Lynch used milkshakes for his highs, so go figure.)
Moving on.
So, the Old Man appears in Manawa's dream in a magic show. Appropriately, as the show has already begun to hint, the old kook is seemingly the original architect behind what is happening to the characters of PA. In the video game, he was an ancient master. This time, he's a magician, and he has some tricks up his sleeve (if you can find me another appropriate, yet less clichéd saying, I'd like to hear it. ...Besides the hat one.) Suddenly…
One Old Man.
Two Old Men.
HUNDREDS OF OLD MEN.
TOO. MANY. OLD MEN.
*regains composure*
What is the significance behind "double?" (Besides the parallel at the end of this episode, that is.) Well, here's a theory of mine that might bridge it all together:
The Old Man created the video game that Kozuka was playing and reenacting. Based on the fact that we saw the moon in this episode (also depicted in conjunction with Manawa operating some kind of broadcast system or recorder, it seems that frequency somehow plays an important part in bringing Lil' Slugger to life. Somehow or another, the game that the Old Man created must have had some kind of glitch in it, and whatever that glitch was, it caused things to happen in the real world that would normally happen in a fantasy world. The Old Man was then soon driven into insanity (or senility), trying to figure out the answer to some kind of equation. This equation that he's trying to solve seems to give the answer to how the chain of events involving Lil' Slugger was instigated.
A second theory that I have based on the way the PA commercials have been formatted is that Lil’ Slugger was a mythological tale of some sort that has existed for centuries. Or perhaps it’s a fusion of the two theories. Ultimately though, by all logic, all signs SOMEHOW point to Maromi, the pink plush doll of definite weirdness.
On a symbolic/thematic scale, there is also something at work which hasn't completely been tied together. It can be deduced that somehow or another, Maromi is an incarnation of Goma, or something similar to that. The question being: If Goma really is paranoia, then what does that mean? How did Goma come into existence for that matter? And why did we not receive a direct answer from the old woman about what Goma really is (in episode 6) if she was supposed to know that information? Was it embedded in her words? Could it have something to do with the idea of her family being torn apart? Do all of the victims now share a bond with each other because of their experiences with Lil’ Slugger? Will I stop asking questions? Yes.
There is also the matter of what the significance of the game metaphor really is, as well as the opening credits and ending credits. First, we know that the Holy Warrior attacks people who are glowing red. People glow red when they are paranoid, presumably. Hence, something that is unclear is whether or not Hirukawa was “red” at the time he was attacked. As far as we know, he was not attacked by Lil’ Slugger and was only hit by Kozuka, considering that he was not rendered unconscious; everyone attacked by Lil’ Slugger so far has experienced the same fate. Thus, chances are that Hirukawa probably took the pill that was given to him by the slimy mob guy, and in turn, became "yellow" (perhaps even green, if we’re going with stoplights here.) But even if this is true, then there is still one problem: Hirukawa still felt trapped at the time, just like the other victims (well, mostly. Keep reading.)
This leads me to believe that there is indeed some kind of catalyst that allows Goma to take over its victims, hence bringing a new idea to the table: Hirukawa was not around whatever this catalyst was. OR, simply put, the pill that Hirukawa took somehow NEGATED the effects of the catalyst. Considering how the first four victims had direct contact with each other, it seems to add up. What I don’t understand is how Kozuka and Hirukawa’s daughter got knocked out under this particular theory. Sure, it makes sense in terms of the paranoia idea, but there’s still something else. Conversely, how Ushiyama got attacked by Lil’ Slugger is a mystery to me. Of course, we didn’t really see his side of the story. As of now, the only possible conclusion that I can make is that Maromi was used by all of the victims. ...Or something.
The intro credits: Everyone is laughing. Why? Is it because they are not afraid of anything any more? Or is it a reverse reaction caused by their paranoia?
The end credits: There is significance to the Crane noise in the background. Somehow, it has something to do with Tsusigo Sagi. I just can’t remember exactly. Also, the order in which the victims are shown appears to be significant, as well as the brief flashes of them (now that we’ve learned of the double idea, it appears that the flash has something to do with that.) Also, the way Manawa is positioned in the circle has relevance. And of course, a giant Maromi in the center.
And so, it ends. Oh wait. No it doesn’t! Let’s talk about Detective Manawa. There is a whole crapload of irony coming his way. Why? Well, now he is AWARE of the fact that Lil’ Slugger goes after people who are paranoid. And now that he is having dreams in which he finds himself surrounded by strange things, he too, feels trapped in a corner. He feels paranoid BECAUSE of Lil Slugger's existence. Talk about paradox-o-rama! When will he be knocked out by Lil’ Slugger? My guess is near the final episode. There are still others that have yet to be slugged, including the old woman, the older detective, and another woman.
Now it really ends. Okay, not quite. There is still one final matter at hand. A disturbing one. Why, unlike the rest of the victims, was Kozuka KILLED!? (or committed suicide.) Was it because he tried to mimic something that already existed? Or it something else?
My head is spinning. Is yours?
Thanks for reading! Once again, respond if you can. I look forward to more commentary.
My Recent Reviews
9.5
Superb
|
FullMetal Alchemist Soul of the Guardian Avg Score: 9.46 Total Ratings: 97 Total Reviews: 4 Users who agree: 4 |
Note: This review is spoiler-free (that is to say, major revelations-wise), except for the last few paragraphs.
I always wondered why this episode was rated the highest (so far) here. Well, I found out why.
"Soul of the Guardian" is where the show comes to the heart of the matter: What is life and death? What is a soul? What is human? All of the themes (religion, science, human control, immortality, emotion, etc.) that we’ve seen so far begin to come to a climax. Appropriately, the layers of truth begin to peel off and more startling discoveries are presented to the viewers and characters simultaneously in each episode of this fantastic "Truth Behind Truths" arc.
Speaking of simultaneous, the juxta-position of Al and Ed’s fights was an excellent device in this episode. Plus, there were no other outside scenes to detract from the tight focus of the story (save that very short scene with Armstrong, Bloch, and Ross, which was fine.) This made the episode feel more real, as if the proverbial camera was actually right in the middle of the fights. Keeping the plot confined to Lab 5, in conjunction with the close-ups and the POVs (i.e. a weary Ed backing away from Number 48 while losing blood, the overhead shot of Al at the end), made “Soul of the Guardian” work really well stylistically and structurally.
The combination of fighting and talking can be a very effective technique. Granted, there are some other fine Adult Swim anime shows that use this, and heck, several other animes out there that haven’t been on Adult Swim. Yet never has talking and fighting been this profound and well-done before (okay, perhaps an exaggeration, but it’s definitely really well done.) This is one of the great things about Fullmetal Alchemist.
What it does and what it discusses appeals to nearly everyone, but it doesn’t have to use clichés, generalizations, and dialogue breaking the fourth wall to make that appeal work. The show always finds innovative ways to let its message be heard, it doesn’t force things down your throat, and it never stops pleasing the masses. There are many examples of this in "Soul of the Guardian," but I’ll just use one to save time: Al, who is young, innocent, and internally vulnerable, plays off of the corrupted, maniacal, and manipulative Number 66 (a quasi-appropriate number) while a more jaded and externally vulnerable Ed faces off with an inverted reflection of his brother…and then some. I doubt I could have plotted out that situation any better.
Okay, I’ll get to the point: the ending. That’s why you’re here reading this after all (at least, that’s why I’m here. If you’re not here for that, then good for you! You have more patience than I do.) Everything about the ending was beautiful: the choir music from episode 3 ("Mother"), the joy of Number 66 having skull-white sparkles appear around him a la Armstrong, the foreboding ironic laughter of Number 48, and Al’s horror (possibly the viewers’ as well) as something utterly horrifying is revealed to him.
Everything just clicks together (or at least, begins to), with parallels from episode 8 ("The Philosopher’s Stone") included. The point that Ed, and possibly the writers, seem to make is that what makes one human is ambiguous. The idea of a soul (or an equivalent of such a thing) is what truly makes one what they are. The idea that Al is convinced into believing that his memories aren’t real is of course, at the center of all of this. We don’t know at this point if they have been fabricated by Ed, but what we do know is that, based on what we’ve seen so far, Al acts just like a human. Number 66 simply telling him something, from my point of view, doesn’t seem to change who Al really is. Try this analogy for size:
When we simply are who are we are and don’t think about it, we are just like Al before Number 66’s revelation. When we take an intro-spective look at ourselves, that’s when we may begin to have doubts about who or what we were before examining ourselves; that’s when we become lost in our thoughts, as Al was in those final moments of the episode. Now, Al must deal with this new feeling, the feeling that he might just be a giant piece of cold, indifferent armor that awaits nothing but the meaningless of the world that vanished from his eyes 4 years ago (I’m trying to be dramatic. Run with me here.) What awaits him? I don’t know, but they had better be good things. Or else. *shakes fist.*
Did I mention we get an expanded ending credits sequence?
In the end, "Soul of the Guardian," while seemingly a short episode (it might just be Ed), is very powerful and very well written. It sets the stage for the twists and turns to come in the next two episodes, and most certainly the final episodes of the show (so I’ve heard.) I highly recommend that you see it. Though…you probably already have. ;)
Report Abuse
Posted Jun 28, 2005
I always wondered why this episode was rated the highest (so far) here. Well, I found out why.
"Soul of the Guardian" is where the show comes to the heart of the matter: What is life and death? What is a soul? What is human? All of the themes (religion, science, human control, immortality, emotion, etc.) that we’ve seen so far begin to come to a climax. Appropriately, the layers of truth begin to peel off and more startling discoveries are presented to the viewers and characters simultaneously in each episode of this fantastic "Truth Behind Truths" arc.
Speaking of simultaneous, the juxta-position of Al and Ed’s fights was an excellent device in this episode. Plus, there were no other outside scenes to detract from the tight focus of the story (save that very short scene with Armstrong, Bloch, and Ross, which was fine.) This made the episode feel more real, as if the proverbial camera was actually right in the middle of the fights. Keeping the plot confined to Lab 5, in conjunction with the close-ups and the POVs (i.e. a weary Ed backing away from Number 48 while losing blood, the overhead shot of Al at the end), made “Soul of the Guardian” work really well stylistically and structurally.
The combination of fighting and talking can be a very effective technique. Granted, there are some other fine Adult Swim anime shows that use this, and heck, several other animes out there that haven’t been on Adult Swim. Yet never has talking and fighting been this profound and well-done before (okay, perhaps an exaggeration, but it’s definitely really well done.) This is one of the great things about Fullmetal Alchemist.
What it does and what it discusses appeals to nearly everyone, but it doesn’t have to use clichés, generalizations, and dialogue breaking the fourth wall to make that appeal work. The show always finds innovative ways to let its message be heard, it doesn’t force things down your throat, and it never stops pleasing the masses. There are many examples of this in "Soul of the Guardian," but I’ll just use one to save time: Al, who is young, innocent, and internally vulnerable, plays off of the corrupted, maniacal, and manipulative Number 66 (a quasi-appropriate number) while a more jaded and externally vulnerable Ed faces off with an inverted reflection of his brother…and then some. I doubt I could have plotted out that situation any better.
Okay, I’ll get to the point: the ending. That’s why you’re here reading this after all (at least, that’s why I’m here. If you’re not here for that, then good for you! You have more patience than I do.) Everything about the ending was beautiful: the choir music from episode 3 ("Mother"), the joy of Number 66 having skull-white sparkles appear around him a la Armstrong, the foreboding ironic laughter of Number 48, and Al’s horror (possibly the viewers’ as well) as something utterly horrifying is revealed to him.
Everything just clicks together (or at least, begins to), with parallels from episode 8 ("The Philosopher’s Stone") included. The point that Ed, and possibly the writers, seem to make is that what makes one human is ambiguous. The idea of a soul (or an equivalent of such a thing) is what truly makes one what they are. The idea that Al is convinced into believing that his memories aren’t real is of course, at the center of all of this. We don’t know at this point if they have been fabricated by Ed, but what we do know is that, based on what we’ve seen so far, Al acts just like a human. Number 66 simply telling him something, from my point of view, doesn’t seem to change who Al really is. Try this analogy for size:
When we simply are who are we are and don’t think about it, we are just like Al before Number 66’s revelation. When we take an intro-spective look at ourselves, that’s when we may begin to have doubts about who or what we were before examining ourselves; that’s when we become lost in our thoughts, as Al was in those final moments of the episode. Now, Al must deal with this new feeling, the feeling that he might just be a giant piece of cold, indifferent armor that awaits nothing but the meaningless of the world that vanished from his eyes 4 years ago (I’m trying to be dramatic. Run with me here.) What awaits him? I don’t know, but they had better be good things. Or else. *shakes fist.*
Did I mention we get an expanded ending credits sequence?
In the end, "Soul of the Guardian," while seemingly a short episode (it might just be Ed), is very powerful and very well written. It sets the stage for the twists and turns to come in the next two episodes, and most certainly the final episodes of the show (so I’ve heard.) I highly recommend that you see it. Though…you probably already have. ;)
10.0
Perfect
|
FullMetal Alchemist Avg Score: 8.97 Total Ratings: 5632 Total Reviews: 609 Users who agree: 5 |
There is a reason why I became so infatuated with this show, to a point where I nearly committed the ultimate "sin:" spoiling myself silly for episodes 27+ (note: spoiling in general is fine, as long as I'm not involved. So no, I won't say, "Sinners!" like Father Cornello.
Or as I like to call him, FatherExploit.)
Anyhow, the reason for all of that is simply because Fullmetal Alchemist is the most awesome anime I have ever seen. Don't let its appearance fool you at first sight. One of the things that makes it so graet is what *doesn't* have. (Oh, sure. It's got chibis, but they work splendidly here.) In other words, it's the anti-prototypical anime.
To specify:
FMa doesn't spin out of control to convey its point. Themes, feelings, and plot devices are often seemlessly interwoven into the plot, in a way that the viewer will be able to notice, but not so as to insult their intelligence. Dolls, for example, is a motif that is used in very different ways, whether literally (Majahal's dolls), figuratively (Mustang pulling Ed's strings), or mixed (the homunculi), creating a ready-steady *wink* theme for all to enjoy. FMa also doesn't just hand-feed you these themes. It lets you think about them, if you desire to do so. A great example of this is episode 10, "The Phantom Thief," which really sets up a aura of ambiguity that the show carries in later in episodes. Without saying more, all in all, FMa perfects the way it conveys its story.
Fma doesn't transcend characters to ridiculous god-like statuses. Not that I don't like shows such as DBZ and Yu Yu Hakusho, but I think we've all seen too much of this. FMa is a show with more down-to-earth (at least for anime) themes and principles, specifically the neverending battle between science and religion. Alchemy and the homunculi are as far as powers go in the show (at least, for now), and I think that's a really nice thing to see. I wouldn't be unhappy if they took it a step further, but considering how most anime today involves "special powers," this is just fine. Plus, when battles and alchemic sequences *do* occur, they're great.
FMa doesn't have one-dimensional characters. Ask anyone who is a fan of FMa their #1 reason for liking the show so much, and the answer is most likely going to be "the characters." Either that, or the story. Characters are flawed, characters are funny, characters are evil, characters have Mr. Clean-like qualities, you name it. FMa's got it.
My personal favorite? Well, to make it fair, I'll name a male and a female. For female, I have Lust-Love. I always fixate on the way she slumps back in the shadows with a look of indifference and makes those wry remarks to her unwitting victims. She'd be simply impeccable if it weren't for her sin and all. *sighs.* As for male, that's tough. I'd be inclined to say Ed and Al as a tie for first place (the brotherly bond is incomparable) and then Hughes and Mustang for second. And just as a random comment, I almost laughed to death when Hughes said, "Well good grief!" on the train in episode 5. Oh Hughes!
Er, getting back on topic.
And finally, unlike SO many anime, FMa is NOT pretentious (unlike me.) It gets to the point, without being too blunt or cryptic. What really helps is the foreshadowing. Foreshadowing is an excellent plot device to use as long as you're willing to go through with part 2 of it (a.k.a. fulfilling the foreshadowing.) FMa delivers that all too well.
So for God's, Ishbal's, or whoever's sake, if you're not watching FMa now, get the DVDs immediately or wait until the show gets repeated for a second time (hopefully) this July. Because before you know it, you'll be Gluttony, and never be full of Fullmetal.
Report Abuse
Posted Jun 6, 2005
Or as I like to call him, FatherExploit.)
Anyhow, the reason for all of that is simply because Fullmetal Alchemist is the most awesome anime I have ever seen. Don't let its appearance fool you at first sight. One of the things that makes it so graet is what *doesn't* have. (Oh, sure. It's got chibis, but they work splendidly here.) In other words, it's the anti-prototypical anime.
To specify:
FMa doesn't spin out of control to convey its point. Themes, feelings, and plot devices are often seemlessly interwoven into the plot, in a way that the viewer will be able to notice, but not so as to insult their intelligence. Dolls, for example, is a motif that is used in very different ways, whether literally (Majahal's dolls), figuratively (Mustang pulling Ed's strings), or mixed (the homunculi), creating a ready-steady *wink* theme for all to enjoy. FMa also doesn't just hand-feed you these themes. It lets you think about them, if you desire to do so. A great example of this is episode 10, "The Phantom Thief," which really sets up a aura of ambiguity that the show carries in later in episodes. Without saying more, all in all, FMa perfects the way it conveys its story.
Fma doesn't transcend characters to ridiculous god-like statuses. Not that I don't like shows such as DBZ and Yu Yu Hakusho, but I think we've all seen too much of this. FMa is a show with more down-to-earth (at least for anime) themes and principles, specifically the neverending battle between science and religion. Alchemy and the homunculi are as far as powers go in the show (at least, for now), and I think that's a really nice thing to see. I wouldn't be unhappy if they took it a step further, but considering how most anime today involves "special powers," this is just fine. Plus, when battles and alchemic sequences *do* occur, they're great.
FMa doesn't have one-dimensional characters. Ask anyone who is a fan of FMa their #1 reason for liking the show so much, and the answer is most likely going to be "the characters." Either that, or the story. Characters are flawed, characters are funny, characters are evil, characters have Mr. Clean-like qualities, you name it. FMa's got it.
My personal favorite? Well, to make it fair, I'll name a male and a female. For female, I have Lust-Love. I always fixate on the way she slumps back in the shadows with a look of indifference and makes those wry remarks to her unwitting victims. She'd be simply impeccable if it weren't for her sin and all. *sighs.* As for male, that's tough. I'd be inclined to say Ed and Al as a tie for first place (the brotherly bond is incomparable) and then Hughes and Mustang for second. And just as a random comment, I almost laughed to death when Hughes said, "Well good grief!" on the train in episode 5. Oh Hughes!
Er, getting back on topic.
And finally, unlike SO many anime, FMa is NOT pretentious (unlike me.) It gets to the point, without being too blunt or cryptic. What really helps is the foreshadowing. Foreshadowing is an excellent plot device to use as long as you're willing to go through with part 2 of it (a.k.a. fulfilling the foreshadowing.) FMa delivers that all too well.
So for God's, Ishbal's, or whoever's sake, if you're not watching FMa now, get the DVDs immediately or wait until the show gets repeated for a second time (hopefully) this July. Because before you know it, you'll be Gluttony, and never be full of Fullmetal.
ldcubed
Last online Oct 19, 2007 2:21 pm PT
Member since Jun 7, 2005
Profile views: 40 (+ 1 new)
Last online Oct 19, 2007 2:21 pm PT
Member since Jun 7, 2005
Profile views: 40 (+ 1 new)
| Send Message | |
| Report Abuse | |
Stats
Level: 4 Completion: 66.25%
Rank: Thighmaster
Forum Posts: 19
ldcubed's Shows Breakdown:
Animation 34: 32.1%
Action/Adventure 23: 21.7%
Drama 17: 16%
Comedy 15: 14.2%
Other 17: 16%
Rank: Thighmaster
Forum Posts: 19
|
Submissions Accepted: 9 Pending: 0 Denied: 1 Total: 10 |
Reviews Shows: 1 Episodes: 1 People: 0 Total: 2 |
Action/Adventure 23: 21.7%
Drama 17: 16%
Comedy 15: 14.2%
Other 17: 16%
About Me
Print
Email
Tag
Digg this








