FORA Politics

Season 2007 Episode 0501

The Silent Ninth Amendment

out of 10
User Rating
0 votes

By Users

Write A Review

Episode Summary

The Silent Ninth Amendment
Daniel Farber discusses the Ninth Amendment in Retained By the People: The "Silent" Ninth Amendment and the Constitutional Rights Americans Don't Know They Have.The Bill of Rights ensures all Americans free speech, the right to trial by jury, and many other important rights. Do additional rights exist, and is the government obliged to recognize them? Is there a right to privacy? To engage in homosexual acts? To marry? Legal scholar Daniel Farber says the express purpose of the Ninth Amendment was to recognize "unenumerated" rights such as these. Yet this amendment has never been the basis for a Supreme Court decision.Simply put, the Ninth states that human rights precede government. The law does not grant these rights and therefore has no authority to take them away. Advocates of "original intent" who demand that the courts recognize only the limited set of rights explicitly listed in the constitution are in fact advocating the opposite of what the Framers intended - they had the foresight to realize they could not possibly anticipate every issue that might arise or what values their descendants would find worthy of protection.Providing critical new support for controversial Supreme Court decisions dealing with abortion, homosexuality, and the right to travel between states, Farber's view doesn't neatly track any political agenda, including his own, making his conclusions challenging for both liberals and conservatives - Cody's Booksmoreless

Episode Discussion

Join the discussion of this episode Episode Discussion

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

See All Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions Trivia & Quotes
  • The President at War

    S 2008 : Ep 0114

    Aired 1/14/08 (1:02:01)

  • The Abortion Controversies

    S 2007 : Ep 1023

    Aired 10/23/07 (1:45:00)

  • Inside the Secret World of the Supreme Court

    S 2007 : Ep 1003

    Aired 10/3/07 (28:34)

  • John McCain in Aspen

    S 2007 : Ep 0815

    Aired 8/15/07 (1:08:14)

Season 2007 Episodes

See All
Ep 1023
The Abortion Controversies
Ep 1218
Sudan's Solution: Linki...
Ep 1218
The Kite Runner: A Pane...
Ep 1214
A Discussion on Pakista...
Ep 1212
Christine Pelosi: Campa...
Ep 1212
Boumediene v. Bush and ...
Ep 1211
Iran and Israel: An Irr...
Ep 1211
Democratic Presidential...
Ep 1210
The Future of Conflict ...
Ep 1210
Reviewing a Decade of C...
Ep 1210
Terje Roed-Larsen on Co...
Ep 1209
Presidential Candidate ...
Ep 1209
Iraq and the Neighbourhood
Ep 1207
Manama Dialogue: Welcom...
Ep 1206
Michael Maccoby: Who Sh...
Ep 1205
Raj Persaud: Powerplay
Ep 1204
The Intelligence Community
Ep 1204
Confronting Iran
Ep 1204
Dennis Ross on the New ...
Ep 1203
Anthony Lappe and Dan G...
Ep 1130
Uncommon Knowledge: Vic...
Ep 1130
Anti-Semitism and Jihad
Ep 1130
Darfur The First Genoci...
Ep 1130
Uncommon Knowledge: Nor...
Ep 1130
Norman Podhoretz
Ep 1129
Pakistan: Its People an...