Forum Network Lectures

Season 2010 Episode 11.14.10

Affirmative Action as Government Speech: The Court and Color

0
N/A
out of 10
User Rating
0 votes

EPISODE REVIEWS
By TV.com Users

Write A Review

Episode Summary

EDIT
Affirmative Action as Government Speech: The Court and Color
AIRED:
Supreme Court affirmative action cases can be divided into two categories. First are those cases in which race-conscious government action provides a material benefit or preference to members of a minority group (e.g., Adarand and Grutter). Second are those cases where the government takes race-conscious action without causing any concrete disadvantage to non-minorities (e.g., Shaw v. Reno, Parents Involved). Under the Courts current Equal Protection doctrine, both categories of cases are presumptively unconstitutional because they both violate the principle of colorblindness. The colorblindness doctrine is best understood as implicitly holding that non-disadvantaging affirmative action constitutes an expressive harm. This program expands upon the existing scholarship by arguing that functionally, the Court has come to view race-conscious, non-disadvantaging government action as a form of prohibited government speech. In essence, the Court has decided that when the government takes such action, it is sending an unconstitutional message that race still matters in our society. Under the government speech doctrine, however, the government is free to express its own message provided it does not restrict or compel private speech. The fact that members of the Court disagree with this message does not make it unconstitutional.moreless
Sunday
No results found.
Monday
No results found.
Tuesday
No results found.

Episode Discussion

Join the discussion of this episode Episode Discussion

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

See All Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions Trivia & Quotes

Season 2010 Episodes

See All
Ep 12.30.10
Whitney Munn: Freedom W...
Ep 12.30.10
Whitney Munn: Freedom W...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
Self-Defense Mechanisms...
Ep 12.29.10
Excerpt from Janice Erl...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
Excerpt from Janice Erl...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
Ep 12.29.10
C Street: The Fundament...
more